Beer Marketer's Insights
Major Distilled Spirits Co Expands on Beer Turf: Diageo Buys Brewery for Smirnoff Ice, Etc
Striking development breaks new ground in several ways. As Guinness UDV North America (a subsidiary of Diageo) buys 3+ mil-bbl Lehigh Valley brewery in Pa, this becomes most significant foray by any international supplier into US beer biz since Alan Bond bought Heileman for over $1 bil in 1987. Makin it even more important: buyer is not only big brewer, but #1 world spirits co with over $2 bil in alc bev oper income. And its pushin branded spirits names in malt-based products. In fact, Guinness actually needs capacity to brew Smirnoff Ice and other malternative/"ready-to-drink" brands to come. Parent co Diageo is bettin big bucks that Smirnoff Ice and whatever else follows are not merely passing fancies. It paid $30 mil for this brewery and will spend about $15 mil to retrofit it. Also paying $30 mil to expand Chi production facility that can make Smirnoff Ice. Could Guinness UDV NA become contract-packing force for other suppliers too, or brew its own beer brands in US? No answers to these questions at presstime. But this move suggests game is changin and points to further blurring of lines between beer and spirits. Deal also immediately improves Pabst finances. Pabst got $30 mil from UDV and $19 mil from Miller (mostly related to plant closing costs). Recall that earlier this yr, Pabst was out-of-compliance with debt covenants.
Wow! Spy games in beer biz: leaked documents, code names, murky motives and race to become world?s largest brewer thru consolidation. With most parties not commenting and no deal announced, unclear how far along any of these contemplated transactions are, or even if they?ll ever happen. But there?s lots of drama and stakes are high. Two possible rival deals outlined in document leaked to British press would form a brewer large enuf to challenge AB for #1 worldwide. One of deals involves Miller too. How?s that grab ya? Interbrew wants to buy or merge with South African Breweries, wrote several British papers based on leaked document, which was prepared by advisers Goldman Sachs and Lazards in Nov for presentation to Interbrew board. Interbrew?s response certainly didn?t rule it out but bid not imminent either. Interbrew acknowledged it did analysis of possible bid as part of annual review of leading international brewers, but insisted analysis at "very preliminary stage, may or may not lead to an offer for SAB." But "no approach has been made" to SAB "on the matter," Interbrew stated.
Document outlined benefits of Interbrew & SAB combo (code names "Ice" and "Zulu") to prevent rival combo codenamed "Scar." "Scar" described in papers as "merger between SAB and Scottish Newcastle Plc with the simultaneous acquisition of Miller," reported Reuters. A separate sheet talked of making offer for SAB after Dec 3 Interbrew board meeting. Only 1 problem: Interbrew had no board meeting scheduled for Dec 3, according to Reuters. At presstime, SAB refused to comment on deal, but announced $537 mil purchase of Honduras brewer. And Interbrew still hasn?t closed on buying Beck?s or selling Carling. What?s significance of Miller?s part in all this? While PM has said for yrs that Miller not for sale, PM has begun more serious discussions with international players in recent months about various options. Miller had no comment at presstime. At the least, these leaks bring into open a new level of possible deals discussed and desired in boardrooms around world in drive towards global brewer consolidation. Interestingly, the 44-page document was mailed anonymously to several British news orgs from Paris, according to the British paper Independent which asked: "Who leaked them and what was their motive?"
Interbrew agreed to pay a startling 13x EBITDA, $1.6 bil for Beck?s 5 mil bbls of beer (plus about 2.5 mil bbls of soft-drinks). That?s several hundred mil more than other brewers thought it was worth. Deal scheduled to close in Feb 2002, but must overcome regulatory hurdles (see below). What will deal mean in US? Last yr, Interbrew?s Labatt USA sold 2.85 mil bbls of imports, got 14 share of segment. Add Beck?s 840,000 bbls, 4.2 share of segment and LUSA would have sold more imports than anyone but Heineken in 2000. Next yr, with Beck?s in portfolio, Labatt USA will sell well over 4 mil bbls of imports and over 5 mil bbls total. Could be neck-and-neck with Heineken as #5 supplier in US. Acquisition of Beck?s 840,000 bbls in US finally makes Interbrew a player in European lager segment in US mkt, where Heineken has long held dominant position. As Labatt USA adds Beck?s to European portfolio of Stella Artois (fast-growing but tiny in US), Carlsberg and Lowenbrau, gets more scale. While Beck?s volume grew a bit in 90s, it dropped from 8.8 share of imports in 90 to 4.2 in 2000. Another interesting point: when deal complete, almost 10% of import biz will have changed hands in 1 yr period, including Beck?s, Molson/Coors joint venture, and US Bevs getting Grolsch.
Acquisition of Beck?s will also affect race between Interbrew and Heineken for #2 position worldwide, Depends on which Bass assets British govt will force Interbrew to sell and to whom. That?s 1 of fascinating angles of Interbrew deal to buy Beck?s. Recall Interbrew bought Bass last yr, but UK regulators put kibosh on deal. Interbrew might just have to divest part of Bass, according to latest rumblings in UK press. Decision expected soon. But Beck?s has 10-yr UK deal with Interbrew?s chief UK competitor Scottish & Newcastle. UK regulators will likely take a close look since Interbrew and S&N will be partners and top 2 competitors in same mkt. Beck?s deal also subject to regulatory approval by European Union and Germany. Interbrew recently bought another 1-mil-bbl brewery in Germany and seems intent on leading consolidation of fragmented industry there. However it all plays out, Interbrew again demonstrated its ambition as global brewing consolidator.
Where There’s Smoke There’s Fire
Lotsa noise lately about a 2- or 3-way deal to merge Miller with Scottish & Newcastle and possibly SAB. Tho proposal has been in air for several mos, publicly (and in BMI) since leaked Interbrew document referred to deal as “Scar,” it got tons of media play this week. And tho Wall St Jnl downplayed deal in 2 different articles, discussions are more advanced and serious than the Journal portrayed. A team of Miller execs has worked on deal for mos with PM. Don’t know whether it will get done, but it has certainly been more than idle chatter about m&a possibilities. Two different media spins: “Miller may be merged into world’s #1 brewer,” Mil Jnl Sentinel headlined on Monday. Said under proposed deal,which could be announced by Mar, PM would keep about 20% of combined co following merger. PM would avoid huge capital gains hit of outright sale, and still get earnings stream from merged brewer. Same day WSJ acknowledged discussions but called them “dormant.” Today, WSJ headlined: “Ailing Miller.” Said: “Selling or Fixing it—Either Choice Is Tough.” But sez no deal “imminent,” and quotes SAB that reports are “speculation.”
How Did Others Do in 4th Q?
Miller’s Much Improved 4th Qtr
Domestic “underlying” shipments up about 275,000 bbls, 3.2% to 8.7 mil bbls in 4th qtr, reported PM. Domestic “underlying” trend (excluding Molson and discontinued brands from 2000 figures) steadily improved as 2001 went on: down –5.3% in 1st qtr, -3.5% in 2d, -3% in 3d and finally +3% in 4th. In 4th qtr, Miller got gains on all core brands including Miller Lite and Gen Draft. Its core brands were up 5.7% for qtr. That’s even tho inventories reduced by a day and a half, sez PM. Meant that even if you include discontinued brands and Molson from last yr, Miller shipped only about 1% less than 4th qtr 2000. That’s big improvement. For full yr, Miller domestic “underlying shipments” down 2.4% to 39.6 mil bbls. (Add in exports and you get 40.5 mil bbl total shipments.) About 70% of Miller’s volume decline “incurred by below premium brands,” wrote PM. Subpremiums down 7.7%, while premium brands off only 1%.
In 1st conference call as incoming PM ceo Louis Camilleri told Wall St: “Our focus has been on the turnaround plan” at Miller and that “hasn’t changed…. John and his team have actually done a terrific job… this time we’re actually seeing better numbers.” (See below.) With new products, etc “we’re hopeful that this year… we’ll finally show stronger performance from Miller.” “Having said that,” Louis added, “we’re not oblivious to the consolidation within the brewing industry and we will explore any options that are in the best interests of shareholders and beyond that I can’t comment.” That’s big change from chairman Geoff Bible’s vehement denials that Miller for sale.
Its not easy to write a year-end message about how wonderful my familys life continues to be in this year of The Atrocities when the tragedy was so close to those we know, when we all felt such heart-searing grief. Actually, that day, we were nowhere near the World Trade Center, which is about 34 miles from our office and home; we were away for a family wedding in an area of a country where we then experienced no warfare and where life then appeared normal, Israel. But here we are nearing the end of an extraordinary year. Irene and I reached a milestoneour 50th wedding anniversary, a record because she stayed with me all these years, and it looks like shes gonna stick around, aiming toward another 25 years. For the milestone our sons Benj, Glen and their wives threw a great party where we saw a lot of friends and even some relatives I wanted to see. In the office, the amount of work I do continues to decrease as Benj and Eric and the entire great crew continue to bust their backs to do the best they can (almost as good as when I was chief honcho). There is a fly in the ointment though: I didnt get to see as many friends in the industry as I did in each of the previous 31 years because I didnt travel as much to meetings and because I had to miss the NBWA meeting in Vegas to be at that wedding in Israel. My old buddies (they sure aint so young) and others should know that I miss those great bull sessions and camaraderie staying up as we did in years past (wasnt so long ago) at the bar till 2 a.m. So to all those I miss and everyone else I wish I knew better, I wish all of you, in this tough, competitive, yet great congenial industry with so many wonderful people, a year of peace, of no terrorism, of personal and family health. Whatever problems America faces, weve all been lucky to be part of this industry and here in this country. Im one of those guys whose parents immigrated here but could have lived in another country and I would have been me there. Thats how lucky I am. Im here. Stay well. Be lucky and healthy all year long and for many years thereafter.
How Heineken Views Global, US Beer Trends; Coming Margin Squeeze in US; Consolidation 101
Key trend in intl beer mkt that Heineken USA prexy Frans van der Minne sees continuing: growth of brands sold at higher prices (premium, global and specialty brands) as consumers drinking "less but better," and growth in low-price/private labels beers, while "standard" segment gets "squeezed." In US tho, low-end aint growing and US has "unique" light beer mkt. Outside of US and Canada, Frans told Beer Inst mtg last mo, light beer "not happening anywhere else." Another interesting point from Frans, suggesting US mkt different than others: Frans said he gets asked why Heineken doesnt build brewery in US; it brews Heineken in lotsa other mkts. "I like to have that small word imported on label." If bottle said "brewed and bottled" somewhere in US, "I think something would get lost." One trend common around world: sales shift to off-premise and consolidation of off-premise retailers. Noted big European retailers like Ahold work on gross margin of 1.2% vs US retailers like Kroger and Publix that make "roughly" 3%. Euro retailers "will come this way," Frans predicted, bring their "technologies and competencies" and "they will come to suppliers... and they will start squeezing our margins." Looking at global consolidation, Frans pointed out that carbonated soft drink industry consolidated after only being in biz for 150 years. Beer biz not consolidated tho its been around for 6000 yrs. Whys that? "I think beer is a much more emotional product," Frans suggested, with more local loyalty. So he sees small breweries surviving. But consolidation of top players will continue, he indicated. Showed slide of top beer mkts in world, comparing mkts like Mexico and Australia, where top 2 or 3 players have 90%+ of total sales ("nicely divided," Frans called em) with mkts like China and Germany, where no single brewer has 10 share. Right now, tho, "nobodys making money" in China or Germany, where "beer margins" are "lowest in the world." As admirer of ex-GE CEO Jack Welch, Frans quoted him sayin co has to "either be #1 or #2 or out." In US, can mean #1 or #2 of segment, if it's big enuf, like imports, where Heineken now #2. "As long as youre #2 or #1, you can make money. #3 you have to struggle. #4 youre gone."
Yuengling and New Belgium; Two Small Brewers Bettin’ Big; Movin’ Up in the Ranks
Yuengling expects to ship about 1.020 mil bbls in 2001, up 11%, according to recent AP article. Thats more than double its 97 volume. Puts Yuengling ahead of Genny as #11 supplier in US and just behind Boston. Boston and Yuengling are the only 2 US brewers below top 4 that sell over 1 mil bbls of their own brands. Yuengling just completed $50-mil, 1.5-mil-bbl brewery, doubling capacity to 3 mil+ bbls, including Tampa plant it bought from Stroh. Most of Yuenglings biz still in Pennsy, NJ and Del, but also sells in Md, Va, Fla and NY. Colos New Belgium is much smaller than Yuengling but soared from just 55,000 bbls in 96 to about 225,000 bbls this yr. Up 60,000 bbls, 36% in 2001 to challenge Redhook as #5 craft brewer. Whats more, New Belgium just broke ground to triple its capacity to 750,000 bbls, reported Rocky Mtn News. Like another successful specialty brewer (Sierra Nevada), and Yuengling, New Belgium expanded distribution slowly. Still only in 12 states. While total small-brewer growth sluggish last 4 yrs, as Petes and Genny dropped sharply and Boston and several other key specialty brewers didnt grow, many smaller brewers doin just fine, points out Brewers Assn America prexy Dan Bradford.

